August 2008
Richard Grefé, the executive director of AIGA and Jessica Friedman Hewitt, the managing director of the Design for Democracy program, did an article for The New York Times "Campaign Stops: Strong opinions on the 2008 Election", citing fundamental flaws of ballot design and how they indelibly affect the voting outcome.
"As the 2008 presidential election approaches, state and local election officials are increasingly concerned about having enough ballots, workers and equipment to handle the predicted high turnout. And with millions of new voters expected to head to the polls, ballot design will be more important
than ever.
Unfortunately, because of technical limitations in voting equipment, misguided local laws, short time frames and tight budgets, many ballots will repeat design mistakes made in past elections. But with access to new ballot design guidelines, officials can now make significant improvements in election accuracy and voter confidence.
During the 2000 presidential election in Palm Beach County in Florida, a confusing “butterfly ballot” design for punch-card voting equipment made it easy to miscast votes for the Reform Party candidate Pat Buchanan that were intended for Al Gore. The confusion called national attention to the design of ballots. But even in 2008, flaws that lead to voter uncertainty and error persist and often go unnoticed.
In an attempt to comply with federal legislation calling for more up-to-date voting equipment, many jurisdictions are trying to reduce voting error rates. Indeed, they are replacing older equipment like punch cards and levers with newer electronic touch-screen machines and optical scanners.
But new equipment does not solve fundamental design flaws.
Earlier this year, the United States Election Assistance Commission distributed guidelines created by professional designers to 6,000 local election officials. And recently, the Brennan Center for Justice at New York University School of Law issued a report outlining the importance of well-designed, easy to understand ballots. This interactive feature identifies common design problems found on optical-scan ballots from previous presidential elections and shows ways to improve clarity and vote accuracy based on the commission’s new guidelines."
Originally published as a blog entry in The New York Times Online
............................................................................
Read AIGA ARTICLES on TAXI Design Network
............................................................................
This news message is supported by The Bazaar, a marketplace to buy and sell creative objects. Earn more revenue by selling your prints, downloadable images, or custom products. Set up your store today and stand a chance to have your products featured on DesignTAXI, towards millions of lovers of creative content!
